I sit here writing you on my Linux-powered netbook, but it's not running Indamixx, an OS I paid almost $150 for. I guess I expected miracles from the folks at 64studio, but didn't get them. Certainly, it's not their fault - they try to do the best they can, and as far as the open-source community goes, they are the only ones pumping money into it and trying to make a valuable product from it. Still, I found the performance to be less than desirable. For example:
- That damn menu is hard to get rid of. I tried various apt-get get-this-crap-out-of-here, but to no avail. You see, 64studio is based on Gnome, and Gnome should not be put on netbooks...it just saps too many precious resources.
- xruns galore with energyXT. I was very upset about this. While Hydrogen ran happily pumping out beats, energyXT sat there, doing nothing, and generated xruns. And we're not talking just a few, a bunch. What a disappointment.
- Did I mention Gnome? Yea, it's there, with all of it's gnome-settings-daemon goodness. The network manager was hard to deal with, and would often fight me when I just wanted to connect to whatever wireless was available.
OK, now for some devil's advocate: All of these problems can be corrected. In the case of #1, the menu can be stopped. (and really, some might not want to - it is updated automagically, and is nice...but RESOURCES PEOPLE, RESOURCES!!!) Issue #3 can be corrected easily with an apt-get remove --purge gnome-desktop-something-or-other, and issue #2 never got any attention, because by this time, I was tired.
When you spend money on an OS, especially one built on Linux and geared to audio production on a niche hardware platform, you expect a few things. First, you should expect that the graphical interface and other programs would be configured to be as lean as possible. This is a netbook, NOT a laptop, and thus everything should be configured as such. Second, all of the configuration should "just work." If the Network Manager is giving issues, it should be removed.
In fact, most
everything in the Indamixx OS (formerly called "Transmission") should be pulled out. Here's what we need: A GUI that somehow shoots the gap between bloated (GNOME) and super-minimal (evilwm or dwm, maybe even fluxbox). XFCE would be a perfect choice for this. Second, this is Linux! Use the tools that already exist for managing things like wireless connections (wireless-tools, anyone?).
AND AWW HELL DON'T EVEN GET ME STARTED ON WIRELESS. Folks, ath5k is NOT ready for the big-time. I'm not sure what the technical details are of this, but I'm running older madwifi drivers and is working very, very well. So ath5k - wtf? I have to set the rate manually? This should not be...
Basically, give us a minimal install CD that installs a bare system, a realtime kernel with all of the supporting modules, a minimal GUI like XFCE that works *with* the system, not against it. Finally, with all of that free space, stuff it full with everything Linux has to offer.
Incidentally, throw in the latest version of Renoise. It rocks. :)
In conclusion, if you buy and Indamixx, buy one that has been tested with your specific hardware. I will not be asking the folks at Indamixx for a refund, because I feel that they will get there, eventually. Maybe not today, maybe not tomorrow, but they are doing The Good Work, and should be supported. Hang in there, guys. Pay more attention to your hardware platform, yes, but hang in there.